I’ll be honest with you – I spent the first year with my cat Mochi thinking she was just… weird. She’d do these random things that made no sense to me, and I’d just shrug it off as “cat being cat.”
Then one day, my friend who’s fostered like 50 cats came over and watched Mochi for five minutes before saying, “Sarah, your cat has been begging you to play with her this entire time.”
Wait, what?
That conversation changed everything. Once I learned to actually READ what Mochi was telling me, I realized she’d been practically screaming “PLAY WITH ME!” for months, and I’d been completely oblivious.
So if you’re sitting there wondering why your cat seems restless, destructive, or just… off lately, I want to share what I’ve learned. Because chances are, your cat is trying to communicate with you too, and you might be missing it just like I did.
Why I’m So Passionate About This Now
Here’s what nobody tells you about cats who don’t get enough play: they don’t just get bored and sleep more. They get frustrated. And frustrated cats become destructive cats.
After ignoring Mochi’s play signals for months, she started knocking EVERYTHING off my counters. I’m talking systematic destruction – she’d walk along and just… sweep. Phone charger, coffee mug, my keys, that plant I was trying to keep alive. Everything.
I thought she was being spiteful. Turns out, she was just desperately trying to entertain herself because I wasn’t picking up on her cues.
One week of proper play sessions later? My counters were safe again. It was like having a completely different cat.
The 10 Signs I Wish I’d Recognized Sooner
Let me walk you through what I’ve learned, because I’m betting your cat is doing at least half of these things right now.
1. The Pre-Pounce Wiggle (AKA The Cutest Thing Ever)
You know that thing where your cat gets low, sticks their butt up in the air, and starts doing this little wiggle dance? Their tail is twitching like crazy and they look absolutely ridiculous?
I used to think Mochi was just stretching weird. Nope. She was locked onto a target (usually my feet) and preparing to pounce. This is prime “grab a toy right now” time.
Now when I see that wiggle, I immediately grab her feather wand. The relief on her face when she finally gets to chase something proper is honestly heartbreaking when I think about all the times I missed this signal.
2. The Toy Delivery Service
This one makes me feel especially dense in hindsight. Luna (my second cat) literally brings me toys. She picks them up in her mouth, walks over to where I’m sitting, drops them at my feet, and looks at me expectantly.
For MONTHS I thought she was just being sweet, sharing her toys with me. I’d pet her and say “thank you, Luna” and go back to whatever I was doing. Meanwhile, she’s probably thinking “Human, I brought you the thing. Make it move. This is how play works.”
Now when she does her toy delivery service, I actually use the toy. Revolutionary concept, right?
3. The Chatty Phase
I live with three cats now, and each one gets vocal in their own way when they want to play. Mochi does these short, demanding meows. Luna trills and chirps. Pixel (my newest addition) literally sounds like he’s complaining about something.
This usually happens around 7 AM and 6 PM – their natural “hunting time.” I used to think they were asking for food, but feeding them didn’t stop the meowing. Playing with them did.
Pay attention to when your cat gets extra talkative. They might be trying to tell you it’s game time.
4. The Wild Eyes Look
Oh my god, the eyes. When cats want to play, their pupils get huge and they get this intense, slightly manic look. I call it Pixel’s “murder eyes” because he looks like he’s plotting something diabolical.
The first time I saw this, I genuinely thought something was wrong with him. Turns out, it’s just their brain switching into hunter mode. Those dilated pupils mean they’re alert, excited, and ready to chase something.
Now when I see murder eyes, I know I have about 30 seconds to provide entertainment before they decide my houseplants look like fun targets.
5. The Velcro Cat Phase
Has your usually independent cat suddenly become your shadow? Following you from room to room, sitting just close enough to stare at you, always somehow right underfoot?
I thought Mochi was being clingy when she started doing this. Actually, she was being hopeful. She was following me around thinking “surely at some point today, my human will notice I exist and want to do something fun together.”
It’s like having a toddler who keeps asking “what are we doing now? how about now? now?” except they’re doing it silently with their presence.
6. The Attention-Seeking Paw Taps
This one starts subtle. Your cat will gently tap your hand while you’re on your phone. Tap your book while you’re reading. Tap your laptop while you’re working.
I used to think this was cute attention-seeking behavior. And it is! But it’s specifically “play attention” they want, not just pets or cuddles.
The tapping escalates if you ignore it. Trust me, you want to respond to the gentle taps before they become insistent swats with claws.
7. The Gravity Experiments
I cannot tell you how long I thought my cats were just jerks who enjoyed breaking my stuff. Pixel has a particular talent for finding the most expensive thing on any surface and slowly, deliberately pushing it toward the edge while making eye contact.
But here’s what I learned: cats don’t knock stuff over to be mean. They do it because moving objects are interesting, and if you’re not providing interesting moving objects (toys), they’ll create their own.
Now when I see someone starting their “gravity experiments,” I interrupt with a proper toy. Works every time.
8. The Halloween Cat Impression
You know that classic arched back, sideways-walking thing cats do? I always associated it with being scared or angry, but my cats do it during play too.
The difference is in the details – during play, their tail is up (not puffed), their ears are forward (not flat), and they’re doing these cute little hops. It’s like they’re trying to look big and intimidating to their “prey.”
Mochi does this when she’s stalking her toy mice, and it’s honestly adorable. She’s basically cosplaying as a fierce predator.
9. The 6 AM Sprint Sessions
Ah, the zoomies. Nothing quite prepares you for the sound of a 12-pound cat tearing through your house at full speed at ungodly hours of the morning.
I used to think this was just random cat weirdness. Now I know it’s pent-up energy looking for an outlet. When cats don’t get enough structured play, they create their own cardio sessions.
The good news? If you tire them out with proper play before bed, the 3 AM races around your apartment happen way less often.
10. The Affectionate But Restless Combo
This one took me the longest to figure out. Sometimes my cats will come for cuddles, but they won’t settle. They’ll purr and knead and headbutt me, but then keep looking around, staying alert instead of relaxing.
I thought they were just being indecisive about whether they wanted attention or not. Actually, they wanted both affection AND activity. They were trying to engage me socially before transitioning to play.
Now I use these moments to move from petting to gentle play, and they’re so much more satisfied afterward.
Got hungry while reading, check out Potluck dishes that everyone loves.
What I Do Now (And What Works)
I Pay Attention to Their Schedule
My cats are most active around 7 AM and 6 PM. Instead of fighting this natural rhythm, I’ve built play sessions into these times. It’s like working with their biology instead of against it.
I Keep Toys Accessible
I have feather wands in three different rooms now. Sounds excessive, but when you see that pre-pounce wiggle, you need to act fast. I’ve also learned to create engaging environments using aquarium throughout my home that naturally encourage play and exploration in cats. Having toys within reach means I can respond immediately instead of losing the moment.
I Let Them “Win”
This was a game-changer. I always end play sessions by letting them catch and “kill” something physical. Usually a small toy mouse they can carry around triumphantly. It satisfies their hunting instinct completely.
I Watch for Their Limits
I learned to recognize when each cat is done. Mochi pants when she’s tired. Luna just stops responding to toys. Pixel gets overstimulated and starts getting aggressive. Knowing when to stop is just as important as knowing when to start.
When I Started Worrying
The only time I involved a vet was when Pixel suddenly stopped wanting to play entirely. Turns out he had a minor injury that made jumping uncomfortable. Once that healed, he was back to his chaotic self.
But sudden changes in play behavior can signal health issues, so don’t ignore them.
What This Changed for Me
I’m not exaggerating when I say that learning to read my cats’ play signals transformed our relationship. They’re happier, less destructive, and honestly? I enjoy their company more now that I understand what they’re trying to tell me.
It also made me realize how much cats are actually communicating with us all the time. We just have to learn their language.
So here’s what I want you to do: for the next week, pay attention. Really pay attention. Notice when your cat is doing these things, and try responding with play instead of just acknowledging them.
I’m betting you’ll be surprised by how often your cat has been asking for your attention, and how much more content they become when you actually give them what they’re asking for.
Because here’s the thing – your cat isn’t being random or difficult. They’re just trying to tell you something, and they’re hoping you’ll eventually figure out what that something is.
I wish I’d figured it out sooner, but I’m so glad I finally did. Your cat will be too.
