Is AI Really Taking Our Jobs, or Are Companies Just Using It as an Excuse?
Qantas is cutting 850 jobs while promising an AI-powered future. But when the work is moving overseas rather than disappearing, we need to ask an uncomfortable question: Is artificial intelligence replacing workers, or is it becoming corporate management's favourite excuse for cutting costs?
Artificial intelligence is coming for your job.
At least, that’s what corporate executives keep telling us.
Every week, another major company announces layoffs, restructuring, or hiring freezes. And increasingly, the explanation sounds remarkably familiar.
- We’re embracing AI.
- We’re transforming our workforce.
- We’re becoming more efficient through automation.
It sounds innovative. It sounds inevitable. And perhaps most importantly, it sounds a lot better than telling employees they’re simply too expensive.
But this week’s announcement from Australian airline Qantas raises a particularly uncomfortable question.
What if AI isn’t actually taking your job? What if your company is just using AI as a convenient excuse to give your job to someone cheaper?
Welcome to the world of AI washing.
Qantas Cuts 850 Jobs. But Is AI Really the Reason?
The affected positions are primarily corporate roles, including finance, procurement, human resources, and marketing.
According to Qantas, the restructuring is intended to modernise outdated systems, simplify operations, and accelerate the company’s adoption of artificial intelligence.
The first changes are expected by mid-2027, with further reductions occurring over the following years.
Sounds like a typical AI transformation story, right?
Except there’s one rather important detail.
Much of the work isn’t actually being eliminated by AI. It’s being transferred to Accenture teams, primarily in India.
And according to Qantas’s own announcement, those services will be transformed further through automation and AI over time.
Read that again.
The jobs are moving offshore first. AI comes later.
That’s a very different story from robots suddenly becoming capable of doing everything those employees previously did.
To be fair, Qantas says its technology infrastructure is outdated, with more than 1,000 legacy applications that weren’t designed to work together. Modernising those systems is a legitimate business objective.
The airline also says it will seek redeployment and retraining opportunities for affected employees.
But the Australian Services Union has questioned the decision, accusing the company of using AI to justify moving Australian jobs overseas.
And it’s difficult to dismiss the obvious question:
If AI has already made these employees unnecessary, why does another company need to hire people to perform their work?
What Exactly Is AI Washing?
You’ve probably heard of greenwashing.
That’s when companies exaggerate their environmental credentials to appear more sustainable than they actually are.
AI washing follows a similar concept.
Companies exaggerate the role of artificial intelligence in their business decisions to appear more innovative, efficient, or technologically advanced.
In the context of layoffs, AI washing means attributing job reductions to AI when the primary reasons may actually be traditional cost-cutting, outsourcing, overhiring, or financial pressure.
Think about how these two announcements sound to investors.
Version A:
We’re cutting 1,000 jobs because operating expenses are too high and we need cheaper labour.
Version B:
We’re transforming our organisation through AI-driven efficiency, optimising our workforce, and positioning ourselves for the next generation of technological innovation.
Both could describe the same restructuring.
But which one sounds better in a shareholder presentation?
Exactly.
This is why AI washing is so attractive.
It turns an unpopular financial decision into an exciting technology strategy.
And in a market where investors are obsessed with artificial intelligence, that distinction can be extremely valuable.
Why Wall Street Loves an AI Layoff
Let’s talk about the financial incentive.
For years, technology companies were rewarded for growing quickly.
More employees meant more engineering capacity, more products, and more opportunities.
Then the economic environment changed.
Investors started demanding profitability, operational discipline, and stronger returns.
Suddenly, having thousands of employees wasn’t necessarily a sign of success anymore.
It was an expense.
Now AI has introduced a particularly useful corporate narrative.
Companies can promise increased productivity while simultaneously reducing headcount.
And instead of appearing to struggle financially, they can present themselves as pioneers of technological transformation.
It’s brilliant from a public-relations perspective.
A University of Sydney Business School professor, Uri Gal, made a similar argument in Reuters’ November 12 reporting, warning that companies have incentives to present ordinary restructuring as AI transformation.
The logic is simple.
Cutting jobs because your business is struggling sounds concerning.
Cutting jobs because your technology is so advanced that you no longer need as many employees sounds impressive.
The same layoffs. A completely different story for investors.
This doesn’t prove that companies are deliberately misleading shareholders.
But it does create a powerful incentive to emphasise AI’s role, even when the actual productivity gains haven’t yet materialised.
But AI Really Is Replacing Some Work
Here’s where the conversation gets complicated.
Not every AI-related layoff is AI washing.
Artificial intelligence genuinely can automate tasks that previously required human employees.
Customer support systems can resolve routine enquiries. AI coding assistants can accelerate software development. Marketing teams can use generative AI to produce content, analyse campaigns, and streamline repetitive work.
Finance departments can automate document processing, reconciliation, and reporting.
These capabilities are real.
And companies would be foolish to ignore them.
We’ve already seen major employers, including Atlassian, WiseTech, and several international technology companies, connect workforce reductions to AI-driven productivity and changing skill requirements.
Some organisations are genuinely redesigning workflows around AI.
Others may be reducing hiring rather than immediately eliminating existing positions.
But there’s an important difference between automating tasks and replacing an entire employee.
A marketing specialist might use AI to write emails faster, but that doesn’t automatically eliminate the need for strategy, creative direction, campaign management, or customer understanding.
A programmer might produce code more quickly, but someone still needs to design systems, review outputs, manage infrastructure, and solve complex problems.
And an AI chatbot handling simple customer enquiries doesn’t mean an organisation can eliminate its entire support team.
AI can make an employee more productive without making that employee unnecessary.
Whether those productivity gains lead to fewer jobs is ultimately a management decision.
The Reserve Bank’s Findings Tell a Different Story
Perhaps the most interesting development this week came from the Reserve Bank of Australia.
On November 9, the RBA published an analysis examining the early effects of AI on the Australian labour market.
Its conclusion?
There is still little evidence that AI has materially disrupted employment across Australia.
The research did identify tentative signs of weaker demand in occupations more exposed to AI, particularly among younger workers.
But those findings were limited, and the RBA cautioned against automatically treating them as proof that AI was responsible.
In a separate speech, the RBA also reported that roughly three-quarters of businesses surveyed through its liaison program had experienced no headcount change attributable to AI.
That’s a very different picture from the dramatic headlines suggesting AI is already replacing everyone.
It doesn’t mean job displacement won’t accelerate.
It means the evidence hasn’t yet caught up with some of the corporate rhetoric.
And that matters.
Because when companies announce thousands of AI-related job cuts while economic researchers find limited evidence of widespread displacement, we should be asking harder questions.
The Real Victims Might Be Entry-Level Workers
There’s another worrying possibility.
AI may not need to eliminate millions of existing jobs to fundamentally change the employment market.
It could simply prevent new jobs from being created.
Imagine a marketing agency with five employees.
Previously, when business grew, it might hire a junior marketer, content writer, or administrative assistant.
Today, the same agency might use AI tools to handle additional work without expanding its team.
Nobody gets fired.
But someone who would previously have been hired never gets the opportunity.
This creates a particularly difficult situation for graduates and early-career professionals.
How do you become an experienced programmer if companies stop hiring junior developers?
How do you become a marketing strategist if the entry-level content and campaign roles disappear?
The RBA’s research suggests younger workers in AI-exposed occupations may already be experiencing some early pressure.
And unlike dramatic corporate layoffs, reduced hiring doesn’t necessarily generate headlines.
The biggest employment impact of AI might not be the jobs it destroys, but the careers it prevents from ever beginning.
Should Companies Be Required to Prove AI Is Replacing Jobs?
Here’s my controversial suggestion.
If a company publicly attributes major layoffs to artificial intelligence, it should be expected to explain what that actually means.
Not necessarily reveal commercially sensitive technology or confidential employee information.
But provide meaningful evidence.
Which processes are being automated?
What measurable productivity improvements have been achieved?
How many positions are genuinely eliminated through automation, and how many are being outsourced or relocated?
Is the technology already performing the work, or is the company restructuring in anticipation of future capabilities?
These questions shouldn’t be unreasonable.
Companies regularly explain the financial benefits of acquisitions, restructuring programs, and major investments.
Why should AI-related workforce reductions receive less scrutiny?
Especially when hundreds or thousands of people’s livelihoods are involved.
Transparency won’t stop technological progress.
But it could make it harder to disguise ordinary cost-cutting as revolutionary innovation.
Final Thoughts: Maybe AI Isn’t the Villain Here
I believe artificial intelligence will fundamentally transform the workforce.
Some jobs will disappear. New careers will emerge. Others will change beyond recognition.
That’s what major technological revolutions do.
But we shouldn’t confuse that long-term transformation with every corporate decision happening today.
Sometimes jobs are lost because technology makes them redundant.
Sometimes jobs are lost because companies want to improve profitability.
And sometimes those two motivations overlap.
The Qantas announcement illustrates just how difficult it can be to separate them.
The company has legitimate reasons to modernise its technology, but the immediate transfer of work to overseas teams makes the claim of AI-driven job reductions worth examining.
Perhaps the most important lesson is that we shouldn’t automatically accept AI as the explanation whenever a company announces layoffs.
AI doesn’t decide to outsource jobs. Executives do.
AI doesn’t decide how productivity gains are distributed between shareholders, customers, and employees.
Management does.
And if companies genuinely want us to celebrate the productivity revolution, they should be willing to explain who benefits from it.
Because there’s something deeply ironic about a technology that promises to free humans from repetitive work becoming the perfect corporate excuse for eliminating their livelihoods.
The question isn’t simply whether AI will take our jobs.
It’s whether we’re allowing companies to blame AI for decisions they would have made anyway.
What do you think? Are we witnessing the beginning of a genuine AI employment revolution, or have corporations discovered the perfect excuse for another round of cost-cutting?
Read More @ General Posting